City Council approves ambulance utility fee to curb mountain EMS costs, dedicate more funds to public safety needs – Updated

ARLINGTON – A $15 ambulance utility fee to slash mounting EMS costs and devote more general fund money for public safety needs was approved by the City Council Monday.

The new fee will appear on city residential and business customers’ utility bills starting in September.

The council had the option to consider a $10 monthly fee presented by City Administrator Paul Ellis that would not have met all immediate needs, vote against the fee altogether and hand the issue back to staff for further research.

The council and staff spent over four years weighing options to get EMS funding and public safety services on a more sustainable track, including forming its own regional fire authority or putting a property tax measure on the ballot.

With the fee in place, the city can move to hire two new police officers, the first added positions since 2003 that aren’t the result of attrition. In addition, three fire personnel and a third police officer will be hired over the next three years, or sooner if grant funding comes through.

Other operational needs met by the fee would include a grant-funded community resource paramedic, domestic violence coordinator for the prosecutor’s office, equipment replacement, fire inspection and fire marshal services, and continued funding for the city’s embedded social worker if the grant expires.

Arlington’s fee would be a restricted fund in the city budget, so monies couldn’t be used for other purposes, he said.

The council added language to their passage of the fee to require quarterly updates starting in September that specifies equipment and manpower purchases, and distribution of funds.

A July 2 public hearing on the fee drew a huge crowd and numerous letters and emails mostly opposed to the fee.

The council voted 4-3 to table the issue to explore more options.

* * *

ARLINGTON – A proposed ambulance utility fee to curb escalating EMS costs and free up city funds for public safety needs is back before the City Council Monday.

If passed, the new fee would begin appearing on residents’ and business owners’ monthly utility bills in September.

City staff are recommending a $15 monthly fee. Council members could opt for that amount or another rate, vote against the fee altogether, or remand the issue back to staff for further research.

Arlington’s fee would be a restricted fund in the city budget, so monies couldn’t be used for other purposes, he said.

If the council adopts the fee, the city would move to hire two police officers. In addition, three fire personnel and a third police officer would be hired over the next three years and possibly by next year if grant funding is awarded.

Other operational needs met by the fee would include a grant-funded community resource paramedic, domestic violence coordinator for the prosecutor’s office, equipment replacement, fire inspection and fire marshal services, and continued funding for the city’s embedded social worker if the grant expires.

“We need more public safety staff to keep up with the growing and aging community, and the rising calls for service,” Mayor Barb Tolbert said, adding the fee also addresses concerns around call response times and increases in homelessness, mental illness and substance abuse.”

A public hearing on July 2 drew a large crowd and numerous letters and emails mostly against the fee. The council voted 4-3 to table the matter.

Several ratepayers said they wanted it to be put to a public vote, questioned whether ambulance service is a bonafide utility, suggested private ambulance service as a cost-cutting alternative, and questioned how ambulance service costs relate to Arlington’s inability to fully staff police and fire services at sustainable levels.

“This fee option is the least impact financially to the citizens, and provides at least five years of sustainability,” City Administrator Paul Ellis said.

City officials compiled a summary sheet to answer the questions from the public hearing, and shared it with the community.

For ratepayers who questioned why the matter isn’t being put to a public vote, state law allows for approval of new and increased taxes, but provides no such mechanism for fees. State law also states that ambulance service can be considered a utility.

As to why contracting with a private ambulance company wasn’t pursued, city officials responded that private service is not available north of Everett as a 9-1-1 EMS option, but if it were to develop it would be considered.

While it may seem odd that an ambulance fee appears on water and sewer utility bills, it is the city’s attempt to keep them all on a single statement to save on printing and mailing costs. If the city billed separately, it would cost ratepayers an extra $50,000 a year.

The City Council and staff have spent over four years weighing options to get EMS funding and public safety services on a more sustainable track, ranging from forming its own regional fire authority or a property tax ballot measure, to tightening internal controls.

Ellis said Arlington cannot continue to subsidize EMS with general fund money that should be used to meet essential public safety goals.

The total cost in 2017 was $6.2 million, with $3 million for fire services and $3.2 million for EMS. While a near 50-50 split strictly on dollar amounts, the actual workload doesn’t match the allocation, with 75 percent of the workload involving EMS calls, Ellis said.

If costs are distributed based on workload, the real cost of EMS service is $4.6 million vs $1.5 million, he added.

However, revenues from an EMS levy capped by state law at 50 cents per $1,000 assessed property value, transport fees and contracts for services with other agencies are only generating $3.1 million, leaving an operating subsidy of $1.5 million, he continued.

Even with these funding mechanisms there is still a shortfall of $1.5 million to cover current costs. To fill that gap, the city has used its general fund to ensure that services are fully funded.

Ellis said the city has tried many ways to address EMS funding shortfalls and address gaps in funding.

For example, the city restructured command in police and fire, increased contract costs for adjacent fire districts, used grants to hire two new officers, deployed an embedded social worker, created a police volunteer program and other efforts.

Ellis pointed out that several other cities across Washington have ambulance utility fees.

Aberdeen charges $22.80, Lynden $11.99 and Port Angeles $8.66, for example.

Arlington provides water, sewer and stormwater services to about 8,000 customers.

More in News

Inslee: Stay home for 2 weeks

By Jerry Cornfield and Zachariah Bryan The Herald OLYMPIA — Gov. Jay… Continue reading

Fences have been put up around Marysville playgrounds to keep kids off. (Steve Powell/Staff Photos)
Marysville leaders concerned as (almost) everything’s closing

By Steve Powell spowell@marysvilleglobe.com MARYSVILLE – Within hours of Gov. Jay Inslee’s… Continue reading

Briefly

Beware of coronavirus scams SEATTLE – U.S. Attorney Brian T. Moran is… Continue reading

Jennifer Thompson, left, and her father Ron Thompson secure a new remembrance plaque to the Oso slide site gate on Sunday, near Oso. Ron Thompson handcrafts a new plaque for the gate every year. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Community remembers Oso slide victims, survivors

By Ben Watanabe The Herald OSO — The power of remembering the… Continue reading

People gather to pick up special allergy meals before leaving Lakewood High School on Wednesday in Marysville. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Districts taking meals to students since schools are closed

By Stephanie Davey The Herald LAKEWOOD — Children wearing pajamas stood outside… Continue reading

Jon Nehring
Letter about coronavirus from Marysville Mayor Jon Nehring

This is an edited version of a letter Marysville Mayor Jon Nehring… Continue reading

DOUGLAS BUell/Staff Photos
                                Lead cook Keina Gowins with Presidents Elementary hands out free grab-and-go breakfasts and lunches to students and parents outside the school Wednesday. Presidents and AHS serve as central kitchen sites for preparing meals, which starting next week will expand to 12 delivery sites from Silvana to Oso. Right, Arlington Food Bank executive director Carla Gastineau and Mike Simpson, food bank board president and owner of Arlington Grocery Outlet, partnered with the district with their Meals Til Monday program, and gave a woman a box of donated food while at Presidents.
Arlington students won’t go hungry during the COVID-19 school closures

ARLINGTON – Arlington schools are closed through April 24 to help fight… Continue reading

Scott Beebe hands out Chromebooks to people in their cars. (Steve Powell/Staff Photos)
Marysville parents anxious to pick up school materials for kids

By Steve Powell spowell@marysvilleglobe.com MARYSVILLE – A few days ago Marysville schools… Continue reading

Jon Nehring
Marysville leaders’ trip to D.C. productive

MARYSVILLE – City leaders recently obtained advice on how to get more… Continue reading

Crews will blow garbage into the street and sweep it up over the next few weeks. The city is asking people to move their cars, trash cans and recycle bins when they come around to help them do a thorough job. (Courtesy Photo)
Marysville shuffles workers due to virus, seeks public’s help for sweepers next week

By Steve Powell spowell@marysvilleglobe. MARYSVILLE – From working from home to teleconferencing… Continue reading

Arlington closed until April 24 amid COVID-19 outbreak: what’s next?

ARLINGTON – When Arlington public school leaders met for a special meeting… Continue reading